The Failure-Mode LibraryVol. #1Check #2 of 20

Brand search grows while non-brand first orders fall

What you see

Brand-search order share rises while non-brand first orders fall and total first orders fail to grow.

Illustration: brand-search first orders rise as non-brand first orders fall; total first orders stay at 1,000.
Total first orders stay at 1,000.

Check this first

Separate searches containing your brand from other searches, then compare verified first orders.

Data needed

  • Paid-search spend and visible queries by date
  • Reviewed brand dictionary and unclassified query coverage
  • First-order source assignment and total store first orders

Run the check

  1. #1

    Classify visible queries with a reviewed brand dictionary. Don't classify from campaign name alone.

  2. #2

    Report unclassified query coverage and platform category totals separately.

  3. #3

    Compare first-order counts, spend, and contribution for each group.

  4. #4

    Inspect non-brand demand, budget limits, stock, and bidding changes.

Calculate

Brand share = brand-assigned first orders / all paid-search-assigned first orders. Keep unclassified search traffic separate.

Compare groups

  • Brand versus non-brand intent
  • First versus repeat order
  • Product
  • Promotion period

What a healthy result looks like

Brand and non-brand results remain clear separately. Total first-order growth supports the claimed acquisition growth.

When to investigate

Compare with matched promotion and seasonal periods. A high brand share alone isn't a failure.

Possible causes

  • Non-brand coverage or prospecting spend fell.
  • Promotions increased demand among people who already knew the brand.

Rule out these explanations

  • Lower competitor brand bidding
  • Cheaper brand clicks without lost non-brand volume
  • Stock restrictions or a planned brand campaign

What to do next

Report brand capture separately. Test the constrained non-brand opportunity before reallocating budget.

What this check can tell you

Brand search can add value. This split can't measure how many brand-search orders would occur without ads.

Use this check with AI
Run a read-only check for: Brand search grows while non-brand first orders fall.
First confirm the available sources, columns, row grain, date basis, currency, and customer definition. Use only authorized data.
Required inputs: Paid-search spend and visible queries by date; Reviewed brand dictionary and unclassified query coverage; First-order source assignment and total store first orders.
Check: Brand-search order share rises while non-brand first orders fall and total first orders fail to grow.
Calculate: Brand share = brand-assigned first orders / all paid-search-assigned first orders. Keep unclassified search traffic separate.
Slice by: Brand versus non-brand intent; First versus repeat order; Product; Promotion period.
Use this comparison rule: Compare with matched promotion and seasonal periods. A high brand share alone isn't a failure.
Show the source totals, calculation, unknown groups, missing inputs, and result. Don't invent fields, thresholds, customer matches, or causal effects.
Rule out: Lower competitor brand bidding; Cheaper brand clicks without lost non-brand volume; Stock restrictions or a planned brand campaign.
Describe the observed signal separately from possible explanations. If the check is incomplete, state the exact data needed.
Make no account or budget changes.
Sources and definitions
  • Google: search terms insightsVisible search terms and grouped category insights have different coverage.Read source
  • Google: conversion liftAttributed results and measured causal lift are different quantities.Read source

Next step

Want help with what you find?

We’ll turn what you find into a plan your team can act on.